How to Source Every Line on a Competitor Battlecard

Every battlecard line needs a source, a date and a grade. Where each kind of claim comes from, and how Mystery Demo sources the lines only said on a call.

Every line on a battlecard ends up as something a rep says to a buyer, and that buyer has often heard the rival’s side first. A careful rep will not risk a line they cannot trace. So a card is only as useful as the sources behind its lines.

A sourced card carries three things on every line: a source, a date and a grade. You can source most lines from your desk in an afternoon. Four kinds of line are different, and they are the ones reps get pushed on in a competitive deal:

The price the rival quotes a buyer like yours, and what moves it.
What the rival’s rep says about your product.
What the rival’s product does when a buyer asks to see it working.
What the rival’s reps promise is coming.

Mystery Demo goes after all four where they come out: the rival’s own sales process, on its calls and in the emails that follow them. It books your competitors’ sales demos as a genuine buyer, records every one, and hands back a board where each finding points to the minute it was said.

Here is how to source a card, one kind of claim at a time, including the one step we take for you.

Give Every Line a Source, a Date and a Grade

Step 1: Split the card into single claims. Most card lines carry two or three claims at once. “Weak on security and slow to onboard” is two claims, and each one needs its own source.

Then give every claim three fields:

Source. The thing you would put on the table if a buyer challenged the line: a saved page, a document, a recording.
Date. When the source said it, which is often months before anyone wrote the line.
Grade. How close the source is to the fact the line states.

The grades come from the ladder in our guide to the evidence grade, and for a battlecard the cut that matters falls between testimony and corroboration:

GradeWhat it isWhat a rep can say
ArtifactThe thing itself: a saved page, a document, a recording. It proves what was published, said or shown, not that it is trueSay what it records, with the date
TestimonyA named person’s own words, on recordSay who said it
CorroborationTwo secondhand sources that got it separately and agreeName both sources
ReportOne source, unchecked, like a buyer’s account in your rep’s notesPlan questions with it; never say it to a buyer
InferenceYour own reasoning, like a roadmap read from job postsKeep it inside the team

Above the cut, a rep can point at the document, the recording or the named person behind a line, as long as the line claims no more than that source records. Below it, the rep is passing on what other people heard, and has to say so.

Some kinds of claim can get above the cut from a desk, and some only from the rival’s own call.

Each Kind of Claim Has Its Own Best Source

Step 2: Tag every claim with its kind. The kind decides where the best source lives and how far a desk can take it. Here is the standard we hold card lines to:

Kind of claimBest desk sourceWhat the rival’s call addsWrite the line as
Price and plansThe pricing page: list prices, plan names, the tiers that say to contact salesThe number quoted to a buyer like yours, the discount, the termsWhat the rep quoted, to which buyer, on which call
What the product doesDocs and the help center: what is documentedWhat the rep showed working on screen, and what they only describedShown live or described only, with the minute
Security and complianceThe trust page: the certificates listedWhat the rep said when asked for the report, and on what termsWhat the rep said, dated, and the report only if you hold it
RoadmapRelease notes and job posts: a direction you inferWhat the rep promised, and by when“Their rep promised…”, never “it ships”
What they say about youNone: their reps say it on callsThe rep’s own words about your productTheir words in quotes, with the minute
Their pitch and pushbackThe homepage headlineThe pitch as spoken, and how the rep answers an objectionThe answer as given, with the minute
Customers and referencesCase studies, logos and reviewsWhich customers the rep names to a buyer like yoursWho the rep named, to which buyer

The second column fills most of a card for free. The third holds the lines a rep gets pushed on, and none of them can be read off a page.

Six Desk Sources, and Where Each One Stops

Step 3: Source everything a desk can reach, and date it. Each desk source proves one thing, and the line you write from it should claim that thing and nothing more.

1. The pricing page, saved with today’s date. An artifact of what the rival publishes, and nothing about the number a rep quotes.
2. The docs, the help center and the API reference. An artifact of what is documented: a strong source for “supports bulk import,” and a weak one for “bulk import works the way the demo showed.”
3. The security or trust page. It lists the certificates the rival holds, but the audit report behind a SOC 2 badge is not meant for the public: most companies share it under an NDA or through a data room. So the page supports “lists SOC 2 on its trust page,” dated, and no more.
4. Customer stories, logos and review sites. Stories and reviews are testimony from customers who agreed to talk, and a logo wall is the rival’s own claim about who buys. They can’t tell you who the rival sells to today, or what its reps tell buyers about you.
5. Release notes, the changelog and job posts. They show what shipped and who the rival is hiring, and any line about what comes next is your own inference. They can’t tell you the roadmap, and neither can a sales call: all a call can capture is what a rep promises.
6. Your reps’ notes and your lost-deal notes. They hold what a buyer told your rep about the rival, which makes them a report of a report. They can’t give you the rival’s own words.

Work through all six and most of the card has a source and a date. The lines left over are the same four a rep gets pushed on: the quoted price, what their rep says about you, what the product does live, and what the reps promise. A desk reaches them only secondhand, because each one comes out to a buyer.

How Mystery Demo Sources the Lines a Desk Can’t Reach

Step 4: Get the rival’s sales calls on the record. This is the step Mystery Demo takes for you, and it fills the third column of the table.

A pricing page, a review site, a battlecard platform and an analyst note all tell you what a rival publishes, or what somebody heard. The rival quotes a price, shows the product, makes promises and talks about you only in its sales process. For those four lines, each of them is secondhand at best.

You can’t take that call as yourself, because the rival’s rep knows your company’s email domain. A team that books its own rivals’ demos gets recognized, or gets the generic tour. Here is how Mystery Demo runs the step instead:

The blank lines become questions. At kickoff, every line still below the cut turns into a question each call has to answer. What does this rival quote a buyer your size, and what does its rep say when your product comes up?
Each rival meets a believable buyer. We write one buying scenario with a real reason to evaluate software, a budget and a deadline, and fit it to the customers each rival sells to. The evaluation is real, because we are evaluating software on your behalf, and the only thing no rival learns is who asked us to look.
The calls run like any serious evaluation. We book through each rival’s front door, then go through the discovery call, the demo, the technical deep dive, the pricing conversation and every follow-up email. The people asking have sold B2B software themselves, so they know which question pulls a rep off the script.
Everything goes on the record. Every call is recorded and every email and piece of collateral is kept. Where the rival’s website, LinkedIn or public news can confirm or contradict what a rep said, we check it before the analysis is written.

One call is evidence of what one rep told one buyer, on one day. A line starts to describe the company, rather than one rep, when the same answer comes back from a different rep on another call. Either way, every answer lands on the board, and the board is where your source column will point.

What Comes Back Is a Recording Behind Every Line

Every recording, transcript and email from a project is listed on the board’s Database page, each with a link that opens the file. Here is that page from our public example board, where the client and every competitor are invented. A real project’s board is built from the calls made for that client.

The Database page of the Mystery Demo example board: a note saying every recording, transcript and asset links to the shared folder, and one competitor’s table of intro and demo recordings, cleaned transcripts, a sales deck, a case study and other collateral.
The Database page of the invented example board: every recording, transcript and document from the calls, one click away.

That page is the far end of your source column. A card line that cites “pricing call, 34:05” points at a recording listed on this page, and anyone who doubts the line can play that minute. Each kind of citation opens something different, and supports a different kind of line:

The line citesIt opensWhat it supports
A call and a minute, like “pricing call, 34:05”The recording on the Database page, at that minuteA line about what the rep said or showed, as an artifact
A document the rival sent, like its proposalThe file itself, kept on the same pageA line about what the rival put in writing, as an artifact
The expert analysisOur reading of the calls, on the rival’s pageYour planning, not a card line on its own: cite the call behind the insight instead

Each rival also gets an expert analysis on its own page, and every insight in it states what it rests on: the meetings, the minutes of recording, the documents, and what the claims were checked against. The analysis says what the calls mean and names the meetings behind each point, so you can check the reading yourself. That sourcing line is the habit your card should copy.

The expert analysis on one competitor’s page of the Mystery Demo example board: a callout naming the meetings, minutes of recording and collateral it draws on, followed by the most important insights from the calls.
One competitor’s expert analysis on the invented example board, with what it rests on stated above the insights.

Battlecard research built from recorded demos adds a finished battlecard for each rival to the board, every line linked to the moment in the recording where the rival said it. Mystery Demo charges a flat €499 per competitor, everything included, and one competitor takes one to two weeks.

Send us the battlecard you trust least, and tell us which rival it is about. On a short intro call we will mark the lines only that rival’s sales calls can source, and then we will go and get them.

Write Each Line Only as Big as Its Source

Step 5: Rewrite each line to the size of its source. A recording of a rep saying a feature ships next quarter proves the rep said it, on that call, to that buyer. It does not prove the feature ships.

The recording is an artifact of what the rep said, and only testimony about whether it is true. Write the line as the promise, and it grades as an artifact. Write it as a fact about the product, and the same recording makes it testimony at best.

Here is the difference on three lines, with invented numbers:

On most cardsGradeRewritten to its sourceGrade
“They discount 30% at quarter end.”Report“Offered 20% off to a 40-seat buyer for signing this month (pricing call, 34:05).”Artifact
“Their reporting is weak.”Inference“Asked to build a custom report, the rep opened a saved template instead (demo, 27:40).”Artifact
“SSO ships next quarter.”Report“Their rep promised SSO ‘next quarter’ (demo, 41:12).”Artifact of the promise

The rewritten lines are smaller, and every one of them survives a buyer asking where it came from. The first one also changed its number: the card had the discount a buyer remembered, and the call had the one the rep offered. Each also hands the buyer something to do, like asking the rival for the same discount, or for the SSO date in writing.

Chief Mystery Officer
Mystery Demo
The line that gets a rep in trouble is often not a false one. It is a true line written one size too big. One rep tells one buyer a feature is coming next quarter, and a few handoffs later the card says the feature ships in March. I would rather hand a rep a smaller sentence they can defend to the minute than a bigger one they have to bluff, because a buyer who has heard both sides can often tell which one they are getting.

Here is a whole card written that way, for Rival A, a golf course software vendor we made up. Every quote, price and minute on it is invented to show the shape.

An invented example battlecard for Rival A, a made-up golf course software vendor, labeled as invented: each line in the rep’s own words with the call and minute it came from and a proof mark such as quoted, shown live, described only or promise only.
An example battlecard. Rival A and every quote, price and minute on it are invented.

The image is what a rep sees. Read as text, each row also shows what happened after the line was said, which is where its proof mark comes from:

Row (Rival A, invented)What their rep saidWhat happened nextProof mark
Their pitch“One system for the tee sheet, the shop and the members.”The opening line on the intro callQuoted (intro call, 02:40)
Price and terms“For two courses you’d be at €1,150 a month, billed yearly.”Not on the pricing page; 10% off offered for signing this monthQuoted (pricing call, 18:05)
Tee sheet“Here’s a booking from the app landing on the sheet.”Shown working on screen, end to endShown live (demo, 11:30)
Member billing“Billing runs off the same member record.”Described, never opened on screenDescribed only (demo, 24:50)
Security“We’re SOC 2, and our security team sends the report.”Report offered after a trial, under an NDAPromise only (demo, 33:15)
Roadmap“Dynamic pricing for tee times lands next quarter.”A promise for later; nothing shownRoadmap (demo, 38:20)
What they say about you“Clubs move to us when the old system can’t run two courses.”Said before your product was named: a dig at whatever the buyer runs todayQuoted (demo, 06:10)
Where they hedgedAsked: “Who sets up the member import?”The rep moved to a customer story and did not answerDeferred (demo, 29:45)

Each line keeps the rep’s own words, the call and the minute, and a mark for how far it was proven. The marks are not the grades: each one says what the recording caught, a quote, a live showing, a promise or a dodge, and every line is an artifact of that call.

The weak marks are where the counter comes from. Member billing was only described and the SOC 2 report is only promised, so the rep’s move is to have the buyer ask Rival A for a live billing run and the report, in writing, before the shortlist call.

Let the Grade Decide What a Rep Can Say

Step 6: Print the rule next to the grade. A rep in a live deal should never have to work out what a grade allows, so copy the third column of the grade table onto the card, next to each line. How the top three grades read on the card:

Artifact. “On their October pricing call, they offered 20% off for signing that month.”
Testimony. “A customer on their case study page says onboarding took two weeks.”
Corroboration. Say it as what two separate sources report, and name both.

A report never gets a buyer-facing line: it goes into your discovery questions. An inference stays inside the team, with the reasoning written next to it.

Step 7: Date every line, and decide what makes it stale. A dated line can be checked again, while an undated one can only be trusted or ignored. Re-source a line when the rival changes its pricing page, ships a release that touches it, or wins a deal on it.

Call lines go stale on their own clock, because a rival can change its pitch without changing a page. When the deals you lose to a rival start sounding different, re-source its call lines first.

A card with a source behind every line is a card your reps can say out loud. Every step here is yours to run this week except Step 4, the rival’s call, which needs a buyer the rival does not recognize. Name the rival your reps meet most and we will take its sales calls as the buyer, so the lines your desk could not source come back with a recording, a date and a grade.

Ready
To Connect?

Let's Connect